Overcompensation vs. opening of the rail market. Expert: It’s a challenge for all of Europe
Poland is preparing for the liberalization of the rail passenger transport market. This change is expected to increase competition among operators and improve service quality, but it is associated with the need to organize the rules of public transport financing. One of the most important topics is accounting for compensation and overcompensation in public service contracts (PSCs).
– Compensation is the difference between the cost of providing public services and the operator’s revenue, plus a reasonable profit. Under EU law, compensation is also any benefit derived from public funds – including rolling stock or infrastructure, explains Stefan Akira Jarecki, Ph.D., professor at the Warsaw University of Technology.
The problem arises in the case of rolling stock projects co-financed by EU funds. Their life cycle is usually 30-40 years, while PSC contracts are valid for 10-15 years. As a result, the operator may end the contract with an unaccounted-for benefit, leading to the risk of overcompensation.
Experts are considering several solutions. The most common is pointing to rolling stock clauses that specify how the assets will be settled at the end of the contract. Also at stake is the transfer of rolling stock to a new operator, leaving it with the existing carrier with an obligation to make it available, or the use of appropriate mechanisms in tenders that eliminate the advantage of owning rolling stock.
– All EU countries will face the same challenge. Poland can benefit from foreign experience, but also become a source of good practices itself, because we have public transportation developed at a high level,” stresses Prof. Jarecki.
Market liberalization is an opportunity for better railroads, but it requires precise rules to ensure fair competition and protect public funds.
The entire interview can be viewed on our YouTube channel or read at openakolej.cupt.gov.pl.
Railroad 2030
21 October 2026 | Railroad 2030
Transport Plan regulation and prior information notice on public passenger transport services
Read about the Minister of Infrastructure’s regulation on the Transport Plan and about the “Prior information notice on public services in passenger transport” published on TED (Tenders Electronic Daily).
More
30 June 2026 | Event reports
Liberalization on the Rails: CEUTP Discusses International Experiences, the Role of the Organizer, and Preparations for Market Liberalization
How can we prepare the rail passenger transport market for greater competition? What lessons can we learn from other European countries? And how can we ensure that the process of change is, above all, beneficial to passengers? These issues were discussed by participants at the 7th workshop of the Transport Research Observatory, titled “Liberalization on the Rails: What Works Abroad?”
More
17 June 2026 | Various
Preliminary Market Consultations on International and Interprovincial Rail Transport
1.2026.WKR_Preliminary Market Consultation on the Provision of Public Mass Transit Services for Interprovincial and International Passenger Rail Transport.
CEUTP, on behalf of the Ministry of Infrastructure, is announcing a Preliminary Market Consultation. Sign up and take part in preparing a key procurement process for passenger rail transport.
More
03 June 2026 | Rail Transportation
New task for CEUTP: market consultation ahead of future rail tenders
The Minister of Infrastructure has tasked the Center for EU Transport Projects with carrying out preliminary market consultations on future procurement of inter-voivodeship and international rail mass passenger transport services.
MoreContact us
Plac Europejski 2, 00-844 Warsaw
Monday – Friday,
hours: 8:15 am – 4:15 pm